Does Being A Cynic Make You More Depressed?
Aug 15th, 2008 by zania
Cynicism Can Suck In The Happiness Stakes!
I am a cynic. No question about that. If anyone makes me an offer on anything, my first thought is always “What’s in it for them?”
When I studied Freudian Psychology at school, one of the first things which really rang a bell with me was that the human psyche is based upon motivation - an inherent need to survive by looking after oneself first (and yes I know that’s a very simplistic version of Freud’s theories, but this post isn’t about that).
You see, life up until then had given me reason to feel this way. Yes, we can love someone dearly and care for their wellbeing very much, but this is not pure unselfish love, because if anything happened to that person, it would make us feel bad.
When I look at politicians telling us their proposals are ‘for the good of all’, my reaction is, “Oh sure. Like we don’t know that you are in this for the money/power/egoism or whatever…”
When a doctor prescribes me a new antidepressant saying “I’ve read very good reports on this one.” My question is, “Yeah, but who produced those reports? Employees of the pharmaceutical company making these drugs?”
In fact, when I see or hear anyone telling me that something is ‘for my good’, my cynical mind clicks in and says, “How on earth do you know what is for my good… unless of course you are basing your assumptions on what is good for you.”
And cynicism has stood me in good stead up till now. In some ways…
Sure, it is very difficult for someone to cheat me (although many still try) and my assessment of the underlying meanings of words is usually proved right.
But does being a cynic make me happy?
I’m not so sure…
Being able to ’see through the crap’ does please me, it’s true. And being able to see beneath the surface can often be good when you are trying to help someone deal with their own distress. And I guess being able to write critical articles and have people say they are good does give me pleasure too…
And I have learned to take complements. At one time, if anyone paid me a complement, my first thought was “why are they saying this?” Now I just say thanks and it feels a whole lot better.
Nowadays I have learned that people can actually be nice because basically they are nice. After all, being nice can make you feel better…
But the underlying principle of my critical (and often personal) thought tends to be “What has motivated this person to do this/say this?”
And when you are trying your best to be a friendly, sociable person, that cynical attitude kinda sucks, because it is like you are viewing everything through a grey mesh of doubt.
And we all know which end of the colour spectrum grey is at…
So is my continued cynical attitude adding to my tendency to depression? Should I try to accept more and criticise less and hope this makes me a happier person? Isn’t it good sometimes just to trust?
Or in today’s World would you say that viewing life with cynicism has to be the only course of action to trust?



